New drugs chip away at cancer
Little by little, new targeted therapies are helping cancer patients live longer, even if they do not offer miraculous cures, researchers said on Sunday.
They are learning how to combine the best new targeted therapies with older drugs to eke out a few extra months or even years for cancer patients - which can mean a lot to a patient hoping to live long enough to see a child graduate or marry.
And each small step builds on earlier progress, so that the overall five-year survival rate for all cancers combined is now 63 percent, according to the American Cancer Society, up from 51 percent in 1975.
“It is sort of like a glacier - you have this slow but extremely powerful movement. But it’s not a fast movement,” Dr. Michael Friedman, chief executive officer of the City of Hope Cancer Center in California, said in an interview.
At first cancer researchers hoped the targeted therapies would prove to be magic bullets that could kill cancer cells without causing too many toxic side-effects, as current chemotherapy and radiation does.
Dr. Margaret Tempero, president of the American Society of Clinical Oncology, said reality was kicking in. Targeted therapies are far too specific to affect a disease that has as many different causes as cancer, she said.
“You can’t expect to hit one part of the pathway and expect everything to regress,” she said in an interview.
“Miraculous effects like Gleevec and CML are probably few and far between.”
But several studies presented at an ongoing ASCO meeting in New Orleans show the new drugs can buy valuable time.
SYNERGISTIC EFFECTS
For instance, adding ImClone Systems Inc.‘s. drug Erbitux to radiation therapy helped head and neck cancer patients live longer without their cancer spreading.
Combining two targeted drugs, Avastin and Tarceva, both made by Genentech with Roche and OSI Pharmaceuticals Inc., kept 71 percent of patients with a hopeless type of kidney cancer alive for six months or more.
And combining Avastin with Pfizer Inc.‘s Camptosar and an older drug called 5-FU helped colon cancer patients live 25.1 months versus 15.8 months for those on more standard therapy.
“There is an idea that these drugs - Erbitux, Tarceva - these drugs that act on cancer’s cellular product are pro-apoptotic. They lead the cell down a pathway that makes it more sensitive to traditional chemotherapy or radiation,” Tempero said.
Apoptosis is programmed cell death, in which a cell self-destructs. This normal process is disrupted in cancer.
“We hope to understand how to put them together thoughtfully as opposed to how it used to be put together - 1 plus 1 equals 2 but now 1 plus 1 is more than 2.”
Some of the targeted drugs also have significant effects on their own when used in the right patients.
“Tarceva, Iressa, Erbitux are showing dramatic effects in 10 percent of patients and that is all,” Friedman said. “We need to learn to aim at the 20 percent who are really going to benefit.”
Millennium Pharmaceuticals’ Velcade helped patients with recurrent multiple myeloma, a hard-to-treat blood cancer that kills 11,000 people a year in the United States. A Dana-Farber Cancer Institute study showed that patients given the old treatment, dexamethasone, saw their cancer start to grow again in an average of 3.6 months while they could stretch that out to 5.7 months on Velcade.
Cancer remains the second leading cause of death in the United States behind heart disease. This year 1.368 million Americans will learn they have cancer and 563,700 will die of it.
Revision date: July 3, 2011
Last revised: by Sebastian Scheller, MD, ScD